Shadow Minister for War Readiness Stuart Anderson MP has continued the fight against Labour's lawfare on veterans who served in Northern Ireland during The Troubles.
Stuart Anderson MP said:
"I was proud to join Conservative colleagues in Parliament voting against Labour's plan to repeal and replace the Legacy Act. Having served in Northern Ireland myself, I know the pressure of having to make split-second decisions after many hours with very little sleep to keep people safe. We ask our troops to go and do the most extreme things in the most difficult conditions. I was pleased that the previous government brought the Legacy Act in because it meant protection for our veterans from vexatious prosecutions. The whole veteran community sees the repealing of this legislation as a body blow. We must have a moral compass to protect those who protected us. It is despicable that Labour is continuing to push through a Bill which will open the door to elderly veterans, already cleared of wrongdoing, being dragged through the courts because of vexatious claims made against them. Only the Conservatives will stand up for our veterans."
Stuart voted against the Government's Northern Ireland Troubles Bill when it returned to the House of Commons on 20th October 2026. Ahead of the key vote, Stuart met with veterans who had assembled outside Parliament to protest against the legislation which threatens to re-open the door to elderly veterans being dragged through the courts because of vexatious claims made against them decades after their retirement. Stuart was joined by Leader of the Opposition Kemi Badenoch MP and members of the Shadow Defence Team including Shadow Defence Secretary James Cartlidge MP and Shadow Minister of State Mark Francois MP.
The Bill repeals and replaces legacy legislation passed by the previous Conservative Government in 2023 which protected veterans from vexatious prosecutions being made against them. Stuart, who served in Northern Ireland for eighteen months during Operation Banner, sat on the Bill Committee for the original Northern Ireland (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act. However, the Labour Government has chosen to continue with its plans to scrap the legislation, which Stuart has said threatens to reopen old wounds. Secretary of State for Northern Ireland Sir Chris Bryant MP has said that amendments to the legislation mean there will be "no equivalence between the lawful action of brave British security forces and the deliberate acts of terrorism" in the Bill. However, even former Labour Armed Forces Minister Al Carns has warned the legislation will cause veterans "untold anguish."
Following an appeal by the Northern Ireland Office, the Supreme Court ruled on 7th May 2026 that the previous legislation did not lead to a “diminution of rights” under the Windsor Framework. Subsequently, Stuart called on the government to drop its plans immediately. Stuart has said it is despicable that the Labour government is continuing to push through the Bill, which will open the door to elderly veterans, already cleared of wrongdoing, being dragged through the courts. South Shropshire is home to more than 4,000 veterans, which accounts for almost one in ten households in the constituency. A petition against Labour's changes previously gained more than 200,000 signatures, including 488 from South Shropshire. Stuart has actively supported the Conservative Party's campaign to scrap the legislation and has made a series of interventions in the House of Commons on behalf of veterans on 14th October 2025 and 21st January 2026. The Conservative Party has made a clear commitment to repeal the legislation if returned to government at the next General Election, which must take place no later than 15th August 2029.
Hansard Transcript:
It an honour to follow the hon. Member for Gower (Tonia Antoniazzi), who speaks eloquently about this topic. I have spoken at length in almost every debate we have had about this matter, having served during the troubles myself, and I contemplated whether I should stand up and speak again today. Like my right hon. Friend the Member for Belfast East (Gavin Robinson), I do not want to say what has already been said over and over and waste time, but the right hon. Member for Leeds South (Hilary Benn) spoke eloquently about the stories that never leave us. We have all heard the stories that never leave us.
I am standing up for the soldiers who served but who did not hear the stories because they were in the stories. They saw this at first hand. Our brave servicemen and women whom we sent to the troubles, or anywhere, had to do some of the most horrendous things in the name of freedom and protecting the country. I have seen that at first hand. Most of these veterans spend their time trying to forget the things that they saw. They come out occasionally, with a few mates around a couple of beers, or they do not come out at all, but we are asking them to relive those things, many years on.
I want to talk about amendments 44 and 47 and new clause 21. Amendment 44 is about following orders. I was a teenager when I deployed during the troubles, and I spent 18 months in Belfast. I was not naive, but I did not know about the political situation. It was completely irrelevant to me. I knew what I had to do. I knew the rules of engagement. We have heard about the training that I would have had as a teenager, and the intelligence briefs I had would have been the best available at the time. I was a young lad, but I was experienced and everybody around me was the same. We knew exactly what we had to do. I did not think, “Is that person a republican or a Protestant? Are they part of the IRA or the Irish National Liberation Army?” Whatever it was, it did not matter: if that person walked around the corner with a rifle, the same rules of engagement applied, no matter what their beliefs or what they were trying to do. There was no politics in it for me.
I was not an officer; I was a rifleman. I was not even at that stage a lance corporal. I was a junior rank. Actually, some would argue that a rifleman is the most senior rank you can ever achieve! As a rifleman, I was following orders. I did not choose where we went, what we did or who we stopped. If we got told to set up a vehicle showing checkpoint so that nobody could go through that place, nobody did. That was the process I had to follow. I might be there with my multiple or my brick—my team—and somebody might have a coffee jar bomb, which was a coffee jar with explosives and junkyard confetti; a whole host of stuff designed to kill and maim. If they were throwing it, I knew—following orders—that while it was still in their hands, I could engage that person and use lethal force to stop them killing me or my friends. The moment their hand had opened and it had left, I could not do that. If you are playing with your kids in the park and you see someone throw a ball, you can see that it takes a split second. You watch that movement—it goes so fast.
I would always have followed my orders, and throughout my operational tour, during the troubles and at any other time, I never witnessed or heard about anybody not following what they were supposed to do, according to the rules of engagement in the JSP—the joint service publication. We all knew exactly what we had to do. I was in Drumcree in ’96 when it kicked off, and it went from a very stable environment...
The hon. Member raises some valid points. A lot of people here have first-hand experience, and the RUC and the military did exceptional work during the troubles—beyond what it is possible even to explain here.
When I look at new clause 21 and amendment 47, I think about how we deal with memory and history. I will explain that in a bit more detail. The Secretary of State said that new clause 21 is illogical. I disagree. I believe that the bar should be exceptionally high.
I went to the Green Jackets reunion this summer. I had not been for 16 years, because—I have spoken of my history and my past—I had to have a break from my past. That is to say nothing against my friends, but I needed to move out of that environment until it was safe for me—given the violence, alcohol and other issues I have had—to go back into it. I had an amazing time at the reunion. I was with my colleagues, and people were telling me stories. Five of us all had exceptionally different memories of a story. People were telling me stories about when I got shot; I knew that they had joined the military five years after, but they were recounting it like they were there with me. It is not that they were making things up; they had heard it that many times that they believed they were there. You are reliving all of these points.
Let us have a look at what it was like to serve in Northern Ireland—this is the point that I want people to grasp in relation to amendment 47. I grew up in Hereford, and my dad was one of the first SAS soldiers to serve in Northern Ireland. We all knew people who had served in Northern Ireland. We knew young soldiers who would come back to the pub—I will not say what age I was first going to the pub—and people would say, “They’ve been over the water.” They did not talk about it; they did not want to talk about it. It was not that they were smashing the place up—some people did, but some reacted differently. They had seen things that their mind had not processed.
I have come through the other side of complex post-traumatic stress. I had therapy. I had witnessed and seen things in my life that my brain could not process. If you see something, you put it into a library in your brain. If you have a traumatic incident, you cannot process it and put it in the library, so it is sort of sat in the foyer. You cannot choose when you pull that up or when you do not. I went through therapy to reprocess all those things in my mind. I have many friends who I know have post-traumatic stress and have not dealt with it—they have just left those issues there. I went through EMDR—eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing— and cognitive behavioural therapy. That took me through things that I had no recollection of, but that the therapist was able to pull out of my brain. I had not remembered those things for many years.
We are going to ask people to go through that process with their memories. I am 50 now—I know that hon. Members are thinking, “You look a bit younger, Stu”—and I was at the very end of Op Banner. I was a teenager. We are asking one and two generations before me to recount things they might have suffered through post-traumatic stress—things that they do not want to remember or possibly cannot remember. If you ask two or three people about the same incident an hour after, they will all have a different reason for it. We have to stand for our veterans and draw a line under this. The Bill is not doing that. The generals, some of whom I served with on operational tours, said that the Bill is a threat to national security, and I believe it is. It impacts on morale phenomenally. I am yet to find a group of veterans—people might disagree—who support it, and I have a very good network of people; my whole life has been spent in defence and security. I have not found anybody who supports what we are doing, and I believe that there will be unintended consequences. I do not believe that we are intentionally going after our veterans, but there will be unintended consequences and we will open the door to our veterans being in the dock for years to come.